Questions to Ask Your DUI Lawyer
Posted April 28th, 2025 by Anthony Carbone, PC.
Categories: Uncategorized.

If you’ve been arrested for driving under the influence, hiring a qualified DUI lawyer is one of the most important steps you can take to protect your rights and your future. But not all attorneys are the same—and finding the right one starts with asking the right questions.
The initial consultation is your opportunity to evaluate whether the lawyer is experienced, responsive, and a good fit for your case. Here’s a list of essential questions to ask your DUI lawyer before deciding to move forward.
1. Do You Specialize in DUI Defense?
DUI law is highly technical and constantly evolving. You don’t want an attorney who occasionally handles DUI cases. Ask if DUI defense is a core part of their practice, and how many similar cases they’ve handled in the past year. Experience matters—especially when it comes to spotting procedural errors and negotiating with local prosecutors.
2. Have You Handled Cases Like Mine?
Not all DUI cases are the same. Some involve first-time offenses, while others include high BAC levels, prior convictions, accidents, or drug impairment. Ask if the lawyer has handled cases with facts similar to yours. Their familiarity with your type of case can influence the defense strategy and potential outcome.
3. What Are the Possible Outcomes?
No lawyer can guarantee a result, but a seasoned DUI attorney should be able to give you an honest assessment of your options. Ask about best-case and worst-case scenarios, possible penalties, and whether alternative sentencing (like probation, classes, or diversion programs) might be available.
Understanding what’s at stake will help you make an informed decision about how to proceed.
4. How Will You Handle My Case?
Some law firms pass clients off to junior associates or legal assistants after the initial consultation. Be clear about who will be managing your case. Will it be the attorney you’re speaking with or someone else? Ask about their communication process and how frequently you’ll receive updates.
You want a lawyer who is hands-on and responsive—not someone who’s too busy to take your calls.
5. What Are Your Fees, and What Do They Cover?
Legal fees can vary significantly. Some DUI lawyers charge a flat rate, while others bill hourly. Ask for a breakdown of costs, including:
- Court appearances
- Pretrial motions
- DMV hearings
- Expert witnesses
- Trial preparation
Make sure you understand what’s included in the quote and whether additional charges could arise if your case goes to trial.
6. Do You Have Experience in the Local Court?
Local knowledge can be a major advantage. A lawyer who regularly appears in your local courthouse likely knows the prosecutors, judges, and court procedures. This familiarity can help in negotiations, scheduling, and understanding what specific judges prioritize in DUI cases.
If your case is in New Jersey, for example, working with a dui lawyer in Jersey City ensures you’re dealing with someone who understands how the Hudson County courts operate.
7. Will You Represent Me at the DMV Hearing?
In many DUI cases, there are two parts: the criminal court case and a separate administrative process through the DMV regarding your driver’s license. Not all lawyers handle both. Ask if the attorney will represent you at the license suspension hearing, and if that service is included in the fee.
This hearing is critical—missing it can mean an automatic suspension, even before your court date arrives.
8. What Is Your Approach to Plea Deals vs. Trials?
Some DUI cases are best resolved through a plea agreement, while others may require going to trial. Ask how the lawyer typically handles cases and whether they’re comfortable and experienced in trial settings. You want someone who’s not afraid to fight in court if needed but who also knows when negotiation is the smarter path.
9. How Long Will My Case Take?
While no lawyer can predict the exact duration, they should be able to give you a rough timeline based on the local court calendar and your case complexity. This helps you plan around work, family, and financial commitments.
10. What Should I Be Doing Right Now?
A proactive attorney will advise you on steps to take while your case is pending—such as enrolling in an alcohol education program, gathering character references, or securing a restricted license. These efforts can sometimes influence the outcome and show the court you’re taking responsibility.
Final Thoughts
Asking the right questions helps you choose a lawyer who is not only experienced but also a good communicator and trusted advocate. DUI charges are serious, and you need someone who is transparent, strategic, and committed to your defense.
If you’ve been charged in or near Hudson County, a skilled dui lawyer in Jersey City can answer your questions, explain your options, and build a strong defense from day one.